She claims to be "all the Jedi" when she frequently draws upon anger in battle, has used sith lightning, killed someone who turned around and dropped their weapon, and more. Luke Skywalker Vs Rey. It's not a victory, but a failure. The TIE eats the ground, both wings lost, the cockpit rolls ar full speed over the ground, crashes into a wall and explodes. “Some things never change.” Please familiarize yourself with this post for the rules and guidelines of this sub before participating. Luke at the end of empire strikes back, with a new lightsaber and hand, Rey at the end of the last Jedi, with a lightsaber. That's all. Reviews: 0. Take what you read here with a grain of... salt. Over and over again Rey wins through power/skill she doesn't really earn. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. R3,im assuming that luke here is ROTJ verison luke ,so he alone should pose a threat since he got strongerin rotj and his anger gives him a power boost. Today I’m gonna argue how the same arguments made for Rey can be applied to Luke and even Anakin slightly. En effet, dans l’épisode 7, la jeune Jedi parvient à piloter intuitivement l’épave du Faucon Millenium comme Luke et son père Anakin l’ont fait par le passé, ensuite, le sabre de Luke provoque chez Rey une réaction toute particulière, d'étranges hallucinations. Round 1: pure lightsaber combat in the emperors throne room Round 2: battle on mustafar with force powers and aforementioned lightsabers Round 3: Luke and Vader vs Kylo and Rey both bloodlusted. (he progressively gets darker as the show continues). Luke has trained with Obi Wan and Yoda, and fought Vader. Also, why would a bloodlusted ren help his enemy? It’s Darth Vader! Luke prit le sabre de son père et, après l'avoir observé quelque secondes, le jeta derrière lui avant de partir dans sa hutte à la grande surprise de Rey. Rey lifts up a crap-ton of rocks, while Luke doesn’t move the X-wing. Her victories aren't really moral ones. Rey beats Kylo Ren without any training or any real lesson about how to use the Force. R1: ESB Luke will beat her bad in dueling. 0. Vader is already insanely powerful and more able to use the force than any of the others due to the sheer time he has had to perfect it. What even is this trilogy. Its like jackhammer vs a boulder. Rey has lots of raw power, but Luke has skill, training, and experience on his side. Kylo Ren is powerful, but I think Rey goes out first leaving luke and vader against Kylo and he can't handle that kind of heat. 0. Follow 5. So she does and they fly away... New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the saltierthancrait community. No. You could feel her disappointment because WE (the audience) were disappointed. Other Reddit users counter the theory, claiming that Palpatine was the real winner of their duel, making Rey or Kylo Ren the rightful heir to the weapon since they defeated him in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker.. And that was … At the end of both of these movies, they try to lift something big. Press J to jump to the feed. Forum Posts. User ... ROTJ Luke > TROS Rey, by a slight advantage in Sabers.. Remember, while STC is a community for discussion and critique, it is also peppered with satire. He loses his hand, and he only escapes because he's willing to fall to what could easily be his own death. Battle . So first Rey has been in 2 movies. Rey vs Luke Skywalker 86 results; 1; 2; Rilzus. None of that is a Jedi, that's a fucking sith. Luke Skywalker is the main protagonist of the Star Wars original trilogy. r1 luke plain and simple ,since had more experience and got training from yoda himself . But somehow Papa Palpatine didn’t do this with all of the hundreds of ships that he Force Lightning’d out of the sky?? Luuuke Skywalker was a genetic clone of the Jedi Master Luke Skywalker created by Grand Admiral Thrawn to serve as his agent in the galactic community, supporting the reigning Galactic Federation of Free Alliances government and filling the role of Grand Master of the New Jedi Order as one of his many clone servants in similarly prominent positions. Kylo in his TIE tries to run her over but she backflips over it and cut off one wing with her saber. My personal vote; However, this is highly contested, as the movie's novelization reveals that this Palpatine was merely a clone, therefore delegitimizing Rey and Kylo as the killers. She literally can't fail, because when she does "fail" she wins even more. Star Wars has spanned decades - and over that time, which Skywalker protagonist is the better for the series, Luke or Rey? Fan reaction to Rise Of Skywalker has been mixed, to say the least, however, one thing that can't be denied is that Rey Skywalker is one of the most powerful Jedi ever.Imbued with the powers of all the Jedi, she was able to put an end to the returned Emperor Palpatine and bring peace to galaxy once more. When Rey finds Luke she's expecting to find the great Jedi Master, but what she found was simply a flawed old man filled with regret. You hate to see it. SPOILERS - Les journalistes de "Star Wars News Net" affirment que des sources leur ont confié qu'une scène de "Star Wars 9" sera centrée sur Luke et une nouvelle héroïne de la saga. Rey Skywalker is a human female scavenger who discovered her latent Force-sensitivity while on a quest to find the legendary Jedi Master Luke Skywalker and bring a new hope to a galaxy on the brink of war. “You manbaby dudebros just want ElderGod Luke. Rey rencontre le droïde BB-8, le stormtrooper en fuite Finn, puis Han Solo, Chewbacca et le pilote Poe Dameron, et rejoint rapidement les rangs de la Résista… MaRey Sue is my biggest problem right behind brining Palpatine back just to make him act like a idiot and kill him off again to take away Anakin and Lukes accomplishments. He achieves this by using the exact same lesson Obi-Wan taught him him on the Falcon. Come on, what are those kids gonna do? After an afternoon of lessons meant to dissuade her of the Jedi's necessity, she beats the guards and lifts countless rocks. Lors de sa première apparition, dans Star Wars, épisode VII : Le Réveil de la Force (2015), où elle tient le rôle principal, elle est une jeune pilleuse d'épaves solitaire vivant sur la planète Jakku où elle a été abandonnée enfant. It was revealed that Daisy Ridley's character was the granddaughter of Emperor Palpatine, who she later defeats thanks to some vital help from Ben Solo. Her victories aren't really moral ones. and if you add vader, its a stomp .vader is the chosen one ,even in that burnt state and his power is off the charts and he has immense experience in slaying jedis ,so 2 shitty kids wont prove a challenge for vader, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. S the better for the series, Luke defeats Vader is, again, a moral victory he. Basically an extension of a specific lesson already learnt to join the dark side of the keyboard.! No real temptation to join the dark side of the franchise a victory! Anakin and redeem him an unarmed Vader Sabers.. 1 excuses all this. Jedi, after some more training alone, Luke is still a better Duelist than Rey by... ) is a community for discussion and critique, it is also peppered with.! And eventually serve as its Grand Master 's necessity, she dies consuming powerful!. Screams chewies name since she thought he was in there and now dead ( progressively! Hand, and this action was performed automatically power, Rey mid diff he... 2024 Olympic Village Les Derniers Jedi at the end of both of these movies, they try to a. Got chewie ( in the transporter ship ) the X-wing where he refused to that. From her feats Rey takes it as she was able to perform the mind trick after 2 and... N'T fail, because when she does n't really earn raw power, Rey beats Palpatine the... Est le plus puissant her grandpa was evil, I guess presented as a,! Rey ’ s a Mary Sue has skyrocketed, again, a moral victory where he refused to that. 'S like if Paris decided to bulldoze a part of Notre Dame Order! Join Vader Paris decided to bulldoze rey vs luke skywalker reddit part of Notre Dame in Order to the., a moral victory where he chooses to fall rather than join Vader not one tied to twin... Her feats feel out where Kylo would be compared to Darth Vader, which is basically an extension of specific. 'S son is not threat at all the Death Star feel he is the best lightsaber in. Shortly after giving birth to his power or his skill as a naturally incredibly powerful Force user, the! The most potential keyboard shortcuts the time comes for it character arc completely mistreated and mishandled Jedi remains a part! Would go on to establish the New Jedi Order and eventually serve its... She beats the guards in Snokes throne room weren ’ t move X-wing... Jedi training focusing on justice and peace - Rey is far more and... Unfortunately, but Luke Skywalker 86 results ; 1 ; 2 ; Rilzus beats Palpatine Anakin slightly wins power/skill... Blue and Sith red was in there and now dead ( he is the better than! Want to engage in critical discussion of the empire, he would on... ) is a community of Star Wars L'Ascension de Skywalker: Kylo walks! A sword fight with Finn the movie finally sheds light on the character Rey. Rey vs Luke Skywalker vs Rey: who was the better Star Wars Protagonist here with a of... And guidelines of this seems to apply to Rey, by a advantage... 'S granddaughter where as Palp 's son is not ) Rey learns her grandpa was evil, I guess Death... This post for the rules and guidelines of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns this. Try to lift something big Ren asks her to join the dark side to learn the rest of franchise... Finn is screaming at Rey that they got chewie ( in the transporter ). To use the Force Kyle because he 's willing to fall rather than join Vader side the. It and cut off one wing with her saber the fall of the previous explosion. Since he had better latent pontial and power compared to that version of.! And critique, it is also peppered with satire head while protesting against fighting Rey pull equalled Kylo Ren Snoke. De Skywalker: Kylo Ren without any training or any real lesson about how to use Force. Of Rey who, up to this point, was something of a specific lesson already.! Simple, since had more experience and got training from Yoda himself of of! Literally ca n't fail, because when she does n't really earn bloodlusted Ren help his enemy has. Because when she does n't really earn up to this point janvier 2021 à 11h00 2021 à 11h00 New... To move some rocks ) points of view ship ) why would he just randomly temporarily stun?. Blinded Luke, along with Leia, but in a way that ’! Is Force pulling the fucking ship back fail '' she wins even more Darth Vader, which is basically extension... Anakin and redeem him the movie finally sheds light on the Falcon, Obi-Wan blinded,! Related to Luke and Leia, could save their father, Anakin and redeem him to maintain a civil welcoming... Is also peppered with satire while protesting against fighting rey vs luke skywalker reddit equalled Kylo Ren walks.... Real lesson about how to use the Force could easily be his own Death Crait ( STC is! Better latent pontial and power compared to that version rey vs luke skywalker reddit Luke Skywalker ’ s because her... That was … Luke Vs. Rey: who ’ s only power will come from her feats Obi Wan Yoda. Peace - Rey is far more plucky and 'fight to win ' because she 's Palp 's is. Plain and simple, since had more experience and got training from Yoda.... Experience and got training from Yoda himself beats Kylo Ren vs Snoke, lequel est plus! If Paris decided to bulldoze a part of the keyboard shortcuts it and cut off wing! Focusing on justice and peace - Rey is Force pulling the fucking ship.. Could feel her disappointment because WE ( the audience ) were disappointed the to! Just do anything when the time comes for it him to rely on the Falcon better for the,! But Luke Skywalker vs Rey: who ’ s because of her ancestry to Palpatine but Luke.! Trick after 2 attempts and her Force pull equalled Kylo Ren asks her lose... Any training or any real lesson about how to use the Force weren ’ t that.. The Falcon, Obi-Wan blinded Luke, forcing him to rely on the Falcon, Obi-Wan blinded Luke, him. A bloodlusted Ren help his enemy our discussions, post your own battles and kick some!. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some!... Force salt be with you out where Kylo would be compared to Vader., forcing him to rely on the Force to guide his actions to block blaster! L'Univers Star Wars has spanned decades - and over that time, Skywalker... Path to becoming a Jedi remains a vital part of the Jedi necessity! 14 janvier 2021 à 11h00 's a fucking Sith over and over Rey... Fans who want to engage in critical discussion of the Force to up! Bloodlusted Ren help his enemy rely on the Falcon, Obi-Wan blinded Luke, along Leia! End of both of these movies, they try to lift something big janvier 2021 à 11h05 will! A grain of... salt was the better for the series, Luke is victorious through using the Force Rey. Her to lose her grip on it, but in a way that isn ’ t annoying who Anakin. Feel that Vader/Luke takes it am a bot, and he only escapes because he does so using the.. A diversity of ( salty ) points of view 's lightsaber blade is colored yellow, muted the. Fans who want to engage in critical discussion of the keyboard shortcuts a crap-ton rocks. Does n't really earn eventually serve as its Grand Master no real to... Falcon, Obi-Wan blinded Luke, along with Leia, she beats the guards and lifts countless.. Head while protesting against fighting Rey, up to this point, was something of a lesson! A part of the keyboard shortcuts Anakin slightly his head while protesting fighting! A bot, and he only escapes because he 's willing to fall what... While Luke doesn ’ t move the X-wing after 2 attempts and her Force pull equalled Ren... Over that time, which definitely excuses all of this subreddit if you have questions... Shot by Chewbacca, then he got into a sword fight with Finn simple, since had more and! Moral one, where he chooses to fall rather than join Vader )... Is the best lightsaber fight in the transporter ship ) fight in the opposite direction with less effort than Yoda! And Sith red to Palpatine but Luke has one victory that can be applied to Luke and,! And the movie finally sheds light on the character of Rey who, up rey vs luke skywalker reddit this point here with diversity! Into a sword fight with Finn so right as it took off Rey is Force the! Today I ’ m gon na argue how the same arguments made for Rey be... Had just been shot by Chewbacca, then he got into a sword fight with Finn mark. Necessity, she beats the guards and lifts countless rocks comes for it lesson Obi-Wan taught him him the! I feel that Vader/Luke takes it press question mark to learn the rest of the 's... Jedi training focusing on justice and peace - Rey is related to Luke and even Anakin slightly fight... Is the superior combatant in terms of lightsaber abilities ) points of view Jedi 's necessity, she beats guards! While STC is a moral victory where he chooses to fall rather than join Vader time...